Rajasthan High Court Refuses to Confirm Death Penalty in Double Murder Case; Awards Life Imprisonment Till Age of 75 Years
Rajasthan High Court Refuses to Confirm Death Penalty in Double Murder Case; Awards Life Imprisonment Till Age of 75 Years The Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench, has declined to confirm the death penalty awarded to an accused convicted of murdering his wife and six-month-old son, holding that the case did not fall within the category of the “rarest of the rare” cases. While upholding the conviction, the Division Bench modified the death sentence to rigorous imprisonment for life until the convict attains the age of 75 years, without the benefit of statutory remission. The judgment was delivered on 3 October 2026 by a Division Bench comprising Justice Mahendar Kumar Goyal and Justice Praveer Bhatnagar in State of Rajasthan v. Pintu Dagar, D.B. Criminal Death Reference No. 1/2026, connected with D.B. Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 304/2026. The judgment, reported as 2026:RJ-JP:37503-DB, is significant for its detailed examination of the circumstances relevant to the confirmation of a death sentence, particularly the accused’s socio-economic background, possibility of reformation, psychiatric evaluation and conduct during incarceration. Background of the Case The matter arose from an incident dated 1 June 2021 in Kota, Rajasthan. As per the prosecution case, the accused, Pintu Dagar, had assaulted his wife, Seema, with an axe. Their six-month-old son, Avinash @ Rajvir, also sustained injuries during the incident and subsequently died while undergoing treatment. An FIR was registered at Police Station Kotwali, Kota City. During the investigation, the police collected witness statements, medical evidence, forensic material, CCTV-related evidence and other incriminating material. The trial was conducted before the Additional Sessions Judge No. 2, Kota, in Sessions Case No. 387/2021. The prosecution examined 23 witnesses and produced 85 documents during the trial. By judgment dated 22 January 2026, the trial court convicted the accused under Section 302 IPC. By a separate order dated 23 January 2026, the accused was sentenced to death along with a fine of Rs. 50,000. Since the trial court had awarded capital punishment, it forwarded the matter to the Rajasthan High Court under Section 366 CrPC for confirmation of the death sentence. The accused also preferred a criminal appeal challenging his conviction and sentence. Accordingly, the High Court heard the death reference and criminal appeal together and decided both through a common judgment. Arguments Raised Before the Rajasthan High Court The defence challenged the conviction on several grounds, primarily contending that the prosecution case was based on circumstantial evidence and that the chain of circumstances was incomplete. It was argued that nobody had actually witnessed the accused assaulting either his wife or his child. The defence also questioned the prosecution’s reliance on CCTV footage and photographs, the recovery of the alleged weapon of offence, the forensic evidence and the application of Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. It was further argued that the prosecution had failed to establish any motive for the commission of the alleged murders. On the question of sentence, the defence submitted that the case did not satisfy the requirements of the rarest of the rare doctrine. The accused was stated to belong to a socio-economically disadvantaged background, had elderly parents and a surviving minor son, and had demonstrated satisfactory conduct during incarceration. The defence accordingly requested the High Court to reject the death reference and set aside the death sentence. Alternatively, it prayed for commutation of the death sentence to life imprisonment. The State, on the other hand, opposed the appeal and sought confirmation of the death sentence, relying upon the nature of the crime, the vulnerability of the victims and the accused’s criminal antecedents. High Court Upholds Conviction Based on Circumstantial Evidence The Rajasthan High Court first examined the challenge to the conviction. The Bench noted that there was no direct evidence of the accused actually inflicting the injuries upon the deceased persons. Therefore, the prosecution case was required to be examined on the principles governing circumstantial evidence. The Court considered the evidence of witnesses who had seen the accused carrying an axe and dragging his blood-soaked wife by her hair near a shop. It also examined the medical evidence, recovery of the weapon and forensic reports. The Court found that the prosecution had established the following important circumstances: The accused, his wife and their younger son had left the house of Rajesh, the maternal uncle of the deceased, on 1 June 2021. At approximately 7 PM, the accused was seen dragging his blood-soaked wife by her hair near the shop of Vijay Kumar Bhoomliya (PW10), while carrying an axe. The accused had attempted to assault his wife again near the shop but fled after an alarm was raised. The medical evidence established that both Seema and Avinash had died due to injuries sustained by them. Human blood was detected on the articles collected during the investigation. The DNA profile obtained from the clothes of the deceased Seema matched with the DNA profile obtained from the accused’s clothes and the recovered axe. The accused failed to provide a plausible explanation regarding the injuries sustained by his wife and son, which the Court considered relevant under Section 106 of the Evidence Act. The Bench also considered the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116, concerning the appreciation of circumstantial evidence. After examining the evidence, the High Court concluded that the prosecution had successfully established the chain of circumstances beyond reasonable doubt. Important Finding Regarding CCTV Photographs and Section 65B Certificate One particularly important aspect of the judgment concerns the admissibility of electronic evidence. The prosecution had relied upon CCTV footage obtained from a shop and photographs prepared from that footage. The defence questioned the admissibility of the photographs on the ground that they were not supported by the mandatory certificate under Section 65B(4) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The High Court accepted this particular objection. The Bench observed that although the CCTV footage had been copied into a pen drive, the pen drive itself was not played before
Death Penalty in India: Law, Rarest of Rare Doctrine & Procedure
Death Penalty in India: Law, Rarest of Rare Doctrine & Procedure The death penalty, also known as capital punishment, is the most severe form of punishment that can be imposed by a criminal court. It involves the execution of a person who has been convicted of an offence punishable with death, following the completion of the prescribed judicial and constitutional procedures. In India, the death penalty remains a legally recognised punishment, but its imposition is subject to strict constitutional safeguards and judicial restrictions. Indian courts have consistently maintained that capital punishment should not be imposed merely because an offence is serious, shocking or attracts widespread public outrage. Instead, the punishment must satisfy the stringent judicial standard known as the rarest of rare doctrine. The debate surrounding capital punishment involves several important legal and constitutional questions. These include the right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, the possibility of judicial error, the objectives of criminal punishment, the rights of victims, the possibility of reformation of offenders and the role of the State in taking away human life. With the introduction of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), which replaced the Indian Penal Code, 1860, the statutory framework governing offences punishable with death has also undergone changes. This article examines the meaning and legal position of the death penalty in India, its constitutional validity, relevant provisions under the BNS, the rarest of rare doctrine, the procedure for awarding a death sentence, mercy petitions and important judgments of the Supreme Court of India. 1. What Is the Meaning of Death Penalty or Capital Punishment? Death penalty refers to a punishment imposed by a competent court whereby a person convicted of a legally specified offence is sentenced to death. The term capital punishment originates from the Latin word capitalis, referring to something relating to the head. Historically, execution methods varied across jurisdictions. In India, the prescribed method of executing a death sentence is hanging by the neck until death. The death penalty is different from life imprisonment. While life imprisonment involves imprisonment for the remainder of the convict’s natural life, subject to applicable remission and commutation provisions, capital punishment results in the termination of the convict’s life through execution. The principal objectives traditionally associated with capital punishment include: Retribution: Punishing an offender for committing an exceptionally grave crime. Deterrence: Discouraging individuals from committing serious offences. Prevention: Permanently preventing the offender from committing further offences. Justice: Recognising the gravity of certain crimes and their consequences for victims and society. However, the legitimacy and effectiveness of these objectives remain subjects of considerable legal, constitutional and academic debate. 2. Is the Death Penalty Legal in India? Yes. The death penalty is constitutionally valid and legally recognised in India. Indian law does not completely abolish capital punishment. However, the Supreme Court has significantly restricted its application through judicial interpretation of the right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution. The constitutional validity of the death penalty was examined by the Supreme Court in the landmark judgment of Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980). The Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of capital punishment but established that it could be imposed only in the rarest of rare cases. This principle means that the death penalty cannot be imposed as a routine punishment, even where the accused has been convicted of murder or another offence punishable with death. The court must independently examine the circumstances of the offence, the background of the accused, the possibility of rehabilitation and all relevant mitigating circumstances. 3. Constitutional Provisions Governing the Death Penalty in India The Constitution of India does not expressly abolish capital punishment. However, several constitutional provisions regulate the exercise of the State’s power to impose and execute a death sentence. Article 14 – Right to Equality Article 14 guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws. The imposition of capital punishment must comply with the principles of fairness, non-arbitrariness and equality. Courts cannot impose the death penalty arbitrarily or discriminate between similarly situated accused persons without legally sustainable reasons. Article 20 – Protection Against Conviction for Offences Article 20 provides important safeguards to persons accused of criminal offences, including: Protection against retrospective criminal punishment. Protection against being prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once. Protection against being compelled to be a witness against oneself. These protections remain applicable in cases involving capital punishment. Article 21 – Right to Life and Personal Liberty Article 21 provides: “No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.” The right to life is the central constitutional provision in the debate concerning capital punishment. The Supreme Court has interpreted Article 21 to require that any procedure resulting in deprivation of life must be fair, just and reasonable. Consequently, a death sentence can only be imposed after following the procedure established by law and satisfying the constitutional standards developed by judicial precedents. Article 72 – Power of the President to Grant Pardon Article 72 empowers the President of India to grant: Pardon; Reprieve; Respite; Remission; Suspension; or Commutation. The President exercises these powers in cases involving punishment by court martial, offences falling within the executive power of the Union, and all cases where a sentence of death has been imposed. Therefore, even after judicial proceedings conclude, a death-row convict may seek constitutional relief through a mercy petition before the President. Article 161 – Power of the Governor to Grant Pardon Article 161 empowers the Governor of a State to grant pardons, reprieves, respites, remissions, suspensions or commutations of sentences in matters falling within the State’s executive power. However, the Governor’s power under Article 161 does not extend to granting a pardon in a case where a death sentence has been imposed. The constitutional power to pardon a death sentence belongs to the President under Article 72. The Governor may, however, suspend, remit or commute a death sentence under the constitutional framework, subject
Circumstantial Evidence in Indian Law: 5 Golden Principles
Circumstantial Evidence in Indian Law: 5 Golden Principles Circumstantial evidence plays a crucial role in criminal trials in India, particularly in murder cases, criminal conspiracy, corruption, financial fraud and other offences where direct evidence may not be available. A court can convict an accused person on the basis of circumstantial evidence alone, provided that the prosecution establishes every essential circumstance and proves a complete chain of evidence pointing towards the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt. The Supreme Court of India has repeatedly emphasised that suspicion, however strong, cannot replace legal proof. The circumstances relied upon by the prosecution must be established through admissible evidence, must be consistent with the guilt of the accused, and must collectively exclude every reasonable hypothesis consistent with innocence. The law governing evidence in India has undergone a statutory transition with the introduction of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA), which came into force on 1 July 2024. However, landmark Supreme Court decisions delivered under the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, continue to provide important guidance on the principles governing circumstantial evidence. This article explains the meaning of circumstantial evidence, the difference between direct and circumstantial evidence, the five golden principles laid down by the Supreme Court, important judicial precedents, the evidentiary value of last-seen evidence and recovery of articles, and the legal considerations relevant to the defence and prosecution in criminal proceedings. What Is Circumstantial Evidence? Circumstantial evidence is evidence of surrounding facts and circumstances from which a court may draw a reasonable inference about a fact in issue, including whether an accused person committed an alleged offence. Unlike direct evidence, circumstantial evidence does not necessarily establish the commission of the offence through the testimony of a person who directly witnessed it. Instead, it establishes a series of connected facts which, when considered together, may prove the prosecution’s case. For example, suppose a person is found murdered inside a locked house. No eyewitness saw the actual killing. However, the prosecution establishes that the accused entered the house shortly before the estimated time of death, the victim was alive when the accused arrived, forensic evidence connects the accused to the crime scene, and other independently established circumstances exclude reasonable alternative explanations. The court must examine whether these facts, considered collectively and in the light of the entire evidence, establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The mere presence of the accused at the scene, a previous dispute with the victim, or an allegedly suspicious explanation would not automatically establish guilt. Each circumstance must be evaluated for its reliability, relevance and evidentiary value. In simple terms: Circumstantial evidence proves a case through the combined effect of established facts rather than necessarily through direct testimony about the commission of the offence itself. Is Circumstantial Evidence Admissible in Indian Courts? Yes. Circumstantial evidence is legally admissible in Indian courts, subject to the rules governing relevance, admissibility and proof. Indian criminal law does not require the prosecution to produce an eyewitness in every case. A conviction can lawfully be based entirely on circumstantial evidence if the evidence satisfies the applicable standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt. The principles governing circumstantial evidence have been explained in several landmark judgments of the Supreme Court, including Hanumant Govind Nargundkar v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1952 SC 343, and Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116. The Supreme Court reiterated these principles in Prem Singh v. State (NCT of Delhi), Criminal Appeal No. 1 of 2023, decided on 2 January 2023. The judgment examined the law relating to circumstantial evidence, the burden of explanation, motive and the assessment of the evidence as a whole. The fundamental principle remains that the prosecution must prove the accused’s guilt through reliable evidence. The absence of direct evidence does not make a prosecution case legally defective, but the absence of a complete and convincing evidentiary chain may make a conviction unsustainable. Circumstantial Evidence Under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 The Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, is the principal legislation governing evidence in judicial proceedings to which it applies. It came into force on 1 July 2024, replacing the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, subject to the applicable repeal and savings provisions. The BSA does not create a separate, exhaustive statutory definition of circumstantial evidence or replace the judicial principles developed by the Supreme Court. Instead, circumstantial evidence is assessed through the statutory rules concerning relevant facts, admissibility, proof, presumptions and the burden of proof. Important provisions include: Section 3: Evidence may be given of facts in issue and relevant facts. Section 6: The relevance of motive, preparation and previous or subsequent conduct. Section 23: The admissibility of confessions made to police officers or while in police custody, including the statutory exception concerning information leading distinctly to the discovery of a fact. Section 63: The statutory framework governing the admissibility of electronic records. Section 109: The burden of proving facts especially within a person’s knowledge. These provisions must be applied according to their precise wording and the facts of the particular case. A relevant circumstance is not automatically sufficient to prove guilt, and a circumstance that is inadmissible or inadequately proved cannot be treated as an established link merely because it appears suspicious. For proceedings connected with the transition from the old criminal laws to the new legislation, the applicable commencement and savings provisions must also be examined. The date of the alleged offence alone should not be treated as the sole test for determining which procedural or evidentiary provisions govern a pending proceeding. Difference Between Direct Evidence and Circumstantial Evidence Direct evidence and circumstantial evidence are two important ways in which facts may be established during a judicial proceeding. The distinction concerns the manner in which evidence proves a fact, rather than whether one category is inherently more reliable than the other. Basis of comparison Direct evidence Circumstantial evidence Meaning Directly establishes a fact through the evidence presented Establishes surrounding facts from which an inference may be drawn Example An eyewitness testifies to seeing the
2020 Murder Case Acquittal uphold by Jaipur High Court, Complainant’s Appeal Dismissed
2020 Murder Case Acquittal uphold by Jaipur High Court, Complainant’s Appeal Dismissed Jaipur: The Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench, has dismissed an appeal challenging the acquittal of a woman accused of murdering her mother-in-law, holding that the prosecution had failed to establish her guilt beyond reasonable doubt. A Division Bench comprising Justice Mahendar Kumar Goyal and Justice Bhuwan Goyal delivered the judgment on October 7, 2026, in D.B. Criminal Appeal No. 317/2026, filed by complainant Bhanwarlal against the acquittal of Reena Sharma. The case arose from an incident dated January 27, 2020, involving the death of Munni Devi. The complainant alleged that the accused had assaulted the deceased with a rolling pin and caused her death by striking her head against a wall. An FIR was registered at Harmada Police Station, Jaipur, under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code. The trial court, by its judgment dated May 18, 2026, acquitted the accused after extending the benefit of doubt. The complainant subsequently challenged the acquittal before the Rajasthan High Court. While examining the evidence, the High Court noted that the prosecution case was based entirely on circumstantial evidence, with no eyewitness to the incident. The Bench observed that the CCTV footage relied upon by the prosecution had not been adequately proved, as the relevant witnesses were not examined and the evidentiary requirements concerning the electronic record were not satisfactorily established. The Court also highlighted discrepancies concerning the alleged recovery of a rolling pin and scissors, the absence of fingerprint evidence, and the lack of injuries on the deceased’s head in the post-mortem report to support the prosecution’s specific allegation regarding the manner of assault. Referring to the principles governing appeals against acquittal, including the Supreme Court’s ruling in Babu Sahebagouda Rudragoudar v. State of Karnataka, the Bench reiterated that an appellate court should not interfere where the trial court’s view is a reasonably possible one. An acquittal strengthens the presumption of innocence, and interference is justified only in limited circumstances, including perversity or material misappreciation of evidence. Finding no legal or factual error in the trial court’s judgment, the High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the acquittal after hearing arguments from both the counsel in jaipur high court. As per the top lawyer in jaipur, The ruling underscores the importance of proving every link in a circumstantial evidence case beyond reasonable doubt, particularly where electronic evidence and alleged recoveries form a crucial part of the prosecution’s case. Read the complete order here
Rajasthan High Court Jaipur Commutes Death Sentence to Life Imprisonment Till 75
Rajasthan High Court Jaipur Commutes Death Sentence to Life Imprisonment Till 75 Jaipur: The Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench, has declined to confirm the death sentence awarded to Pintu Dagar, who was convicted of murdering his wife and six-month-old son in Kota in June 2021. While upholding his conviction, the Division Bench directed that he undergo rigorous imprisonment for life until he attains the age of 75 years, without the benefit of statutory remission. The judgment was delivered on October 3, 2026, by a Division Bench comprising Justice Mahendar Kumar Goyal and Justice Praveer Bhatnagar. The Court was examining a death reference submitted by the trial court for confirmation of the capital punishment, along with the criminal appeal filed by the convict challenging his conviction and sentence. Court Upholds Conviction Based on Evidence According to the prosecution, the incident occurred on June 1, 2021, in Kota. The accused was alleged to have murdered his wife, Seema, and their infant son, Avinash alias Rajvir. The prosecution relied on the testimony of witnesses who stated that they had seen the accused dragging his blood-soaked wife by her hair while carrying an axe. The Court also considered the recovery of the weapon, bloodstained clothes, forensic evidence and DNA analysis. The High Court observed that the prosecution had established the chain of circumstances connecting the accused with the crime beyond reasonable doubt. It found no sufficient ground to interfere with the trial court’s finding of guilt and accordingly maintained the conviction for murder. Death Penalty Not Justified Merely Because the Crime Was Heinous The principal question before the High Court was whether the case fell within the category of the “rarest of the rare” cases warranting capital punishment. The Bench reiterated that the gravity and brutality of a crime, by themselves, cannot be the sole basis for imposing the death penalty. Courts must carefully balance the aggravating circumstances against the mitigating circumstances and determine whether the alternative of life imprisonment is unquestionably foreclosed. In reaching its conclusion, the Court considered the absence of an established motive, the circumstances surrounding the incident, the accused’s personal and socio-economic background, his conduct in prison and the material concerning his potential for reformation. The Court noted that the prosecution had not established that the murders were pre-planned or cold-blooded. The evidence indicated that the accused and his wife had been married for approximately 15 years and had two sons. The prosecution was unable to establish what had transpired between the couple in the period preceding the incident. The Bench emphasised that even in a grave double-murder case, the death penalty cannot be imposed without applying the constitutional principles governing capital sentencing. Importance of Supreme Court Guidelines on Sentencing The judgment discusses the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab, Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab and Manoj v. State of Madhya Pradesh, among other decisions. The Bench also considered the Supreme Court’s directions in Aman Singh and Another v. State of Bihar concerning the collection and assessment of material relating to aggravating and mitigating circumstances in death penalty cases. Such material may include the convict’s family history, education, socio-economic circumstances, criminal antecedents, psychological and psychiatric assessments, prison conduct and prospects of rehabilitation. The High Court examined the reports placed before it, including the prison conduct report and psychiatric evaluation. The records indicated satisfactory and peaceful conduct in custody, while the psychiatric assessment did not identify a gross psychiatric disorder. The Court also considered the circumstances of the convict’s surviving elder son, who was being cared for by his grandparents, and the family’s limited financial resources. Life Imprisonment Until the Age of 75 After weighing the aggravating and mitigating circumstances, the Bench concluded that the case did not meet the legal threshold for the “rarest of the rare” category. However, the Court did not consider ordinary life imprisonment subject to the usual remission framework to be the appropriate sentence in the circumstances. Referring to the principles governing special-category life sentences, including those discussed in Swamy Shraddananda v. State of Karnataka and Navas alias Mulanavas v. State of Kerala, the Bench ordered rigorous imprisonment for life until the convict attains the age of 75 years, without the benefit of statutory remission. The Court consequently answered the death reference in the negative and partly allowed the criminal appeal only to the extent of modifying the sentence. The conviction and fine imposed by the trial court were maintained. The best lawyer in jaipur, have commended and welcomed the order of the honourable Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Key Legal Takeaway The ruling underscores an important distinction in criminal sentencing: upholding a conviction for a heinous offence does not automatically justify the death penalty. Even where guilt is established beyond reasonable doubt, the court must independently assess the appropriate punishment in accordance with the principles of proportionality, the balance between aggravating and mitigating circumstances, and the possibility of reformation. The judgment reinforces the requirement that capital punishment be reserved for cases in which the alternative of life imprisonment is unquestionably foreclosed, while recognising that courts may, in appropriate cases, impose a special-category life sentence for a specified period without statutory remission. Read the complete order here
Rajasthan High Court Denies Bail to Accused in Kanhaiya Lal Murder Case, Upholds Strict UAPA Bail Restrictions
Rajasthan High Court Denies Bail to Accused in Kanhaiya Lal Murder Case, Upholds Strict UAPA Bail Restrictions Jaipur, October 3, 2026: The Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench, has dismissed a batch of criminal appeals filed by five accused seeking regular bail in the high-profile Kanhaiya Lal murder case investigated by the National Investigation Agency (NIA). The Division Bench of Chief Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal and Justice Sameer Jain delivered its judgment on October 3, 2026, reaffirming the stringent standards governing bail under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA). The appeals challenged orders of the Special NIA Court, Jaipur, which had rejected the bail applications of the accused. The appellants argued that they had been in custody for over four years, that the trial was likely to take considerable time and that prolonged incarceration violated their fundamental right to personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution. The defence also questioned the evidence linking them to the alleged conspiracy and relied on Supreme Court judgments, including Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb, to contend that constitutional protections could override statutory restrictions on bail in cases of excessive trial delays. Opposing the appeals, the NIA lawyer in jaipur argued that the accused had played specific roles in a larger criminal conspiracy and that witness statements, call detail records, video recordings and weapon recoveries supported the prosecution’s case. The agency also submitted that the trial was progressing expeditiously, with nearly 30 material witnesses already examined and the witness list reduced from approximately 180 to 89. The High Court examined the restrictions under Section 43D(5) of the UAPA and the constitutional safeguards available under Article 21. It reiterated that courts must assess whether the prosecution material establishes a prima facie case without conducting a mini-trial at the bail stage. The Bench observed that prolonged incarceration can justify bail even in UAPA cases where a timely trial is not realistically possible. However, it found that the circumstances of the present case did not warrant such relief, particularly given the progress of the trial and the specific allegations against the appellants. Consequently, the High Court upheld the orders rejecting bail and dismissed all five appeals, while clarifying that its observations would not affect the final determination of the evidence during trial. Copy of Order Bhuvnesh Kumar GoyalHigh Court Advocate in Jaipur
Jaipur High Court Granted Bail in Rape Case: Prolonged Relationship, Consent and Promise of Marriage Considered

Jaipur High Court Granted Bail in Rape Case Prolonged Relationship, Consent and Promise of Marriage Considered The Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench, has granted bail to an accused in a case involving allegations of rape, deception, promise of marriage, harassment and other offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) and the Information Technology Act. The order was passed on 18 September 2026 by Hon’ble Mr. Justice Farjand Ali in S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous Bail Application No. 10257/2026, arising out of FIR No. 38/2026 registered at Police Station Vaishali Nagar, Jaipur (West). The bail application was filed under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS). The decision is particularly relevant to bail proceedings where the prosecution case concerns a relationship between two adults, allegations relating to a promise of marriage, and questions surrounding the nature and voluntariness of the physical relationship. The Court, while deciding the bail application, specifically examined the duration and nature of the relationship, repeated meetings, travelling and staying together, continuation of physical relations, and the complainant’s knowledge of the accused’s existing marital status. Importantly, the High Court clarified that its observations were confined to the consideration of bail and would not prejudice the trial court while deciding the case on merits. What Was the Case Before the Rajasthan High Court? The accused-petitioner was Dinesh, aged about 48 years, who was confined at Central Jail, Jaipur. The case arose from FIR No. 38/2026, registered at Police Station Vaishali Nagar, Jaipur (West). The FIR invoked: Section 64(1) BNS Section 69 BNS Section 82(2) BNS Section 318(2) BNS Section 351(2) BNS Section 66D of the Information Technology Act The order records these offences in its opening case details. The complainant, according to the FIR as recorded by the Court, was a 52-year-old divorcee residing in Pune. She allegedly came into contact with the accused through Shaadi.com, where he represented himself as a divorcee and allegedly assured her of marriage. The FIR alleged that after she came to Jaipur on 11 October 2025, the accused established physical relations with her against her will and thereafter continued the relationship on the assurance that he would marry her. The complainant further alleged that the accused repeatedly postponed the marriage and subsequently disclosed that he was already married and living with his wife and son. Allegations were also made concerning threats, harassment and pressure relating to pregnancy and miscarriage. These are allegations recorded from the FIR, and the High Court’s bail order does not constitute a final determination of their truth. What Did the Accused Argue for Bail? On behalf of the accused, it was argued that the ingredients of the alleged offences were not made out and that continued incarceration was not warranted. The defence also contended that the accused had been implicated on the basis of conjectures and surmises. The prosecution opposed the bail application and submitted that the accused should not be enlarged on bail. The High Court considered the submissions of both sides and examined the material available on record before reaching its decision on bail. Why Did the Rajasthan High Court Grant Bail? One of the most significant aspects of the order is the Court’s examination of the overall nature and duration of the relationship. The Court noted that the material on record indicated that the complainant had: remained in the company of the petitioner for a considerable period; voluntarily accompanied him on several occasions; travelled with him; stayed with him at different places; met him repeatedly; and continued physical relations over a substantial period. The Court observed that these circumstances, taken cumulatively, prima facie indicated her continued association with the petitioner. The Court also noted that, according to the material available on record, the complainant was aware that the petitioner was married and nevertheless continued associating with him for a considerable period. This aspect became one of the circumstances considered by the Court while deciding the bail application. Rajasthan High Court on Consent in a Rape Case A particularly important portion of the order concerns the distinction between consent and subsequent grievance or disappointment arising from a relationship. The Court observed that an allegation of rape necessarily involves sexual intercourse against the will or without the consent of the prosecutrix. However, at the stage of bail, the Court found that the circumstances emerging from the record did not disclose a continuous absence of willingness on the complainant’s part. The Court referred to the prolonged association, repeated meetings, travelling together, staying together and continuation of physical relations over a considerable period as circumstances that were, at that stage, suggestive of voluntary participation in the relationship. This observation was made for the limited purpose of deciding bail. What Did the Court Say About the Promise of Marriage? The Court also considered the subsequent revelation regarding the accused’s marital status and the fact that the relationship did not culminate in marriage. The Court observed that these circumstances could undoubtedly have caused distress and grievance to the complainant. However, it held that such subsequent events, by themselves, could not retrospectively render every act of physical intimacy between the parties as an act committed against her will. The Court emphasised that the surrounding circumstances and conduct of the parties must be considered in their entirety. This is an important aspect for understanding the order: the Court did not finally decide whether the complainant’s consent was legally valid or whether it was vitiated. Rather, the Court expressly stated that this ultimate question would have to be examined at the appropriate stage of trial. Did the Rajasthan High Court Decide the Accused Was Innocent? No. The order is a bail order, not a judgment after trial. The Court specifically stated that the question of whether the complainant consented to the physical relationship and whether such consent was legally vitiated was a matter to be examined at the appropriate stage of trial. Further, while granting bail, the Court expressly stated that it was not expressing any final opinion on the merits of
POCSO Case Procedure: FIR to Trial & Judgment

POCSO Case Procedure: FIR to Trial & Judgment A POCSO case can be significantly different from an ordinary criminal case because the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act) provides special procedures for reporting, investigation, recording of the child’s statement, medical examination, trial and protection of the child’s identity. If an FIR is registered under the POCSO Act, the accused and the victim’s family should understand the complete legal process—from registration of FIR and police investigation to arrest, bail, filing of the charge-sheet, framing of charges, evidence, cross-examination, final arguments and judgment. This article explains the POCSO case procedure in India, including the procedure followed before POCSO Special Courts in Jaipur, Rajasthan, and other parts of the country. Important: The procedural law applicable to criminal investigations and trials has changed with the introduction of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS). For cases governed by the new criminal laws, relevant BNSS provisions apply alongside the POCSO Act. What Is a POCSO Case? The POCSO Act is a special legislation enacted to protect children below the age of 18 years from sexual assault, sexual harassment and pornography-related offences. The Act covers offences including: Penetrative sexual assault under Section 3 Aggravated penetrative sexual assault under Section 5 Sexual assault under Section 7 Aggravated sexual assault under Section 9 Sexual harassment under Section 11 Use of a child for pornographic purposes under Section 13 Abetment and attempt of POCSO offences The Act also establishes a special procedure intended to make the investigation and trial more child-friendly. Sections 24 to 40 of the Act deal extensively with recording of statements, medical examination, Special Courts, presumptions, trial procedure and protection of the child during evidence. POCSO Case Procedure: Step-by-Step The broad procedure in a POCSO case can be understood as follows: Complaint/Information → FIR → Child’s Statement → Medical Examination → Investigation → Arrest/Bail → Collection of Evidence → Charge-Sheet → Cognizance → Supply of Documents → Framing of Charges → Prosecution Evidence → Cross-Examination → Statement of Accused → Defence Evidence → Final Arguments → Judgment → Appeal Stage What Happens Important Point 1. FIR Police register information regarding alleged offence POCSO + BNS sections may be invoked 2. Child’s Statement Statement recorded in child-friendly manner Section 24 POCSO 3.Magistrate Statement Statement may be recorded before Magistrate Section 25 POCSO / applicable BNSS provision 4. Medical Examination Child medically examined Section 27 POCSO 5. Investigation Police collect documentary, forensic, digital and oral evidence Investigation strategy is critical 6. Arrest Accused may be arrested depending on facts and law Arrest and FIR are separate issues 7. Bail Accused can seek appropriate bail remedy Depends on offence and stage 8. Age Determination Court determines whether victim was below 18 Extremely important in many cases 9. Charge-sheet Police submit investigation report Section 193 BNSS 10. Special Court POCSO Special Court proceeds with case Section 28 POCSO 11. Charges Court determines offences for trial Defence can challenge prosecution case where legally permissible 12. Prosecution Evidence Prosecution examines witnesses Includes child, doctors, police, forensic witnesses etc. 13. Cross-examination Defence tests prosecution evidence Subject to child-protection safeguards 14. Accused Statement Accused is examined regarding circumstances appearing against him Applicable BNSS procedure 15. Defence Evidence Defence may produce evidence Not mandatory in every case 16. Final Arguments Both sides present their case Evidence is analysed as a whole 17. Judgment Court acquits or convicts Reasons must be recorded 18. Sentence Sentence considered after conviction Depends on applicable POCSO offence 19. Appeal Aggrieved party may pursue statutory appellate remedy Forum and limitation depend on applicable law Each stage is explained below. 1. Registration of FIR in a POCSO Case A POCSO case ordinarily begins when information regarding an alleged sexual offence against a child reaches the police. Section 19 of the POCSO Act imposes obligations relating to reporting of offences. Once information discloses a cognizable offence, the police can register an FIR and commence investigation. Under the present criminal procedure framework, Section 173 of the BNSS deals with information relating to cognizable offences. The FIR may contain allegations attracting provisions of both: POCSO Act; and Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS). For example, depending upon the allegations and facts, a case may involve POCSO provisions along with provisions relating to rape, kidnapping, criminal intimidation or other offences under the BNS. Can a POCSO FIR be quashed? In appropriate cases, an accused may approach the High Court seeking quashing of the FIR or criminal proceedings. However, the availability of such a remedy depends heavily upon the facts, evidence, statutory provisions and the stage of the proceedings. A mere settlement between the accused and the victim’s family does not automatically terminate a POCSO prosecution. 2. Recording of the Child’s Statement One of the most important stages in a POCSO case is recording the statement of the child. Section 24 of the POCSO Act lays down special requirements for recording the child’s statement. The objective is to ensure that the child is not unnecessarily exposed to a hostile or intimidating environment. The law requires that the statement be recorded in a child-sensitive manner. The statement should, as far as practicable, be recorded: at the residence of the child or another place where the child ordinarily resides; by a woman police officer not below the rank prescribed by law; without bringing the child into contact with the accused; in a manner that does not cause unnecessary distress to the child. The law also contemplates recording through audio-video means wherever possible. 3. Statement Before the Magistrate The child’s statement may also be recorded before a Magistrate under the applicable procedural law. Under the POCSO framework, Section 25 specifically deals with recording of the statement of a child by a Magistrate. Under the current criminal procedure regime, Section 183 BNSS deals with recording of confessions and statements by a Magistrate. This statement can become an important piece of the prosecution case. However, it is important to understand that a statement recorded during investigation is not
Sexting Between Teenagers – Is It a POCSO Offence?
Sexting Between Teenagers – Is It a POCSO Offence in India? Sexting generally refers to sending, receiving or exchanging sexually explicit messages, intimate photographs, videos or other sexual content through mobile phones, WhatsApp, Instagram, Snapchat or other digital platforms. Among teenagers, sexting may sometimes occur between two people who are in a relationship and may even be mutually consensual. However, Indian law takes a particularly strict approach when a person below the age of 18 is involved. The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act) defines a child as a person below 18 years of age and contains specific provisions dealing with sexual harassment, sexual exploitation and pornographic material involving children. Therefore, an important question arises: Is sexting between two teenagers a POCSO offence even when both of them consent? The answer depends substantially on what was exchanged, the ages of the persons involved, the nature of the communication, whether photographs or videos were involved, and the surrounding circumstances. What Does “Sexting” Mean? Indian statutes do not specifically use the word “sexting.” The term is generally used to describe digital communication having a sexual nature. It can include: Sexually explicit text messages Sexual conversations through social media Sending intimate or nude photographs Sending sexually explicit videos Asking another person to send intimate photographs Taking or creating intimate images for another person Forwarding or sharing intimate images Threatening to circulate intimate images Sharing sexual content involving a child Sexting can therefore cover conduct ranging from sexual conversations to the creation and distribution of sexually explicit images. Government and child-protection materials recognise that sexting can involve both sexual conversations and the creation or sharing of intimate images by children. Is Sexting Between Teenagers a POCSO Offence? Not every instance of teenage communication can automatically be labelled a POCSO offence. However, certain forms of sexting can clearly fall within provisions of the POCSO Act. This distinction is important. For example, there is a significant legal difference between: Two teenagers exchanging ordinary romantic messages; Two teenagers having sexually explicit conversations; One teenager repeatedly sending sexually explicit messages to another; A teenager asking another minor to send an intimate photograph; A minor sending an intimate photograph to another minor; A person storing or forwarding sexually explicit material depicting a child; and An adult engaging in sexual communication with a minor. The applicable legal provision may differ depending upon the facts. Who Is a “Child” Under POCSO? Under Section 2(1)(d) of the POCSO Act, a child means any person below 18 years of age. This means that the law does not make a distinction between: a 10-year-old, a 15-year-old, a 17-year-old, or two teenagers who are only a few months apart in age. For purposes of the statutory definition, all persons below 18 are children. This becomes particularly important in cases involving teenage relationships. Sexting Through Sexual Messages – Can Section 11 POCSO Apply? Section 11 of the POCSO Act deals with sexual harassment of a child. Among other things, the provision covers certain conduct involving sexual words, sounds, gestures, objects and communication. It also specifically recognises following, watching or contacting a child through electronic, digital or other means in circumstances involving sexual intent. Therefore, digital communication can potentially come within the scope of Section 11. For example, depending upon the facts, conduct may raise a POCSO issue where a person: repeatedly contacts a child with sexual intent; sends sexually explicit material to a child; asks a child to display his or her body; attempts to obtain sexual photographs from a child; threatens to use a sexual depiction of a child; or entices a child for pornographic purposes. Section 12 provides punishment for sexual harassment under Section 11, which may extend to three years’ imprisonment and fine. Important point The mere fact that two teenagers exchanged messages does not, by itself, answer the legal question. The content of the messages, the intention behind the communication and the surrounding circumstances matter. What If Teenagers Exchange Nude or Intimate Photographs? This is considerably more serious. The POCSO Act specifically contains provisions dealing with the use of children for pornographic purposes. Section 13 provides that using a child in any form of media, including electronic or computer technology, for sexual gratification can constitute an offence. The provision expressly covers preparation, production, offering, transmitting, publishing, facilitating and distributing pornographic material involving a child. Consequently, the fact that a photograph was: voluntarily taken, voluntarily sent, exchanged privately, or created by the child himself or herself does not automatically remove the photograph from the legal framework concerning child sexual abuse material. The legal consequences can become particularly serious when such material is forwarded, distributed, published or stored. What About Section 15 of the POCSO Act? Section 15 deals with storage or possession of pornographic material involving a child and provides a graded punishment structure depending upon the circumstances. This is one of the most important provisions when dealing with sexting involving intimate images of minors. The Supreme Court has clarified the scope of Section 15 and the concept of possession in cases involving child sexual abuse material. The Court has explained that possession can include constructive possession where the person exercises the requisite degree of control over the material. It has also recognised the relevance of digital devices and electronic material in this context. Therefore, a teenager should not assume that deleting a photograph from a chat immediately eliminates every possible legal issue. Copies may exist: on the phone, in cloud storage, in backups, in messaging applications, on another person’s device, or elsewhere in digital form. What If Both Teenagers Consented? This is one of the most frequently misunderstood aspects of POCSO law. Consent does not automatically make sexual conduct involving a child lawful. The POCSO Act is designed to protect persons below 18 from sexual offences and pornography. The statutory framework does not create a general exception simply because two teenagers claim that their conduct was consensual. However, “consensual” does not mean that every interaction between two
Protest Petition after filing of FR (Final Report)

Protest Petition after filing of FR (Final Report) A Protest Petition is a legal remedy available to a complainant, informant, or victim when the police file a Final Report (Closure Report) instead of a charge-sheet after completing the investigation of a criminal case. Through a Protest Petition, the complainant requests the Judicial Magistrate to reject the police’s conclusions and independently examine whether sufficient material exists to proceed against the accused. In Indian criminal law, a Protest Petition plays a crucial role in ensuring that justice is not denied because of an incomplete, unfair, or legally incorrect police investigation. Although the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) does not specifically define the term “Protest Petition,” the remedy has been firmly recognized through landmark judgments of the Supreme Court of India and various High Courts. The fundamental principle governing a Protest Petition is simple: the opinion of the investigating officer is not binding upon the Magistrate. The final decision on whether criminal proceedings should continue always rests with the court. Why is a Protest Petition Important? A Protest Petition acts as an important safeguard within the Indian criminal justice system. Police officers investigate criminal offences and submit their findings before the court, but they do not determine whether the accused should ultimately face criminal proceedings. That responsibility belongs exclusively to the Magistrate. Where a complainant believes that the investigating agency has ignored material evidence, failed to examine important witnesses, misapplied the law, or conducted a biased investigation, a Protest Petition provides an opportunity to seek judicial scrutiny of the Final Report. This remedy protects victims against arbitrary investigations, strengthens judicial oversight over police action, reinforces public confidence in the administration of justice, and helps ensure that genuine criminal cases are not closed solely because of an erroneous police opinion. What is a Final Report or Closure Report? After completing the investigation of a cognizable offence, the investigating officer submits a police report before the jurisdictional Magistrate. Where sufficient evidence exists against the accused, the police file a charge-sheet recommending prosecution. Conversely, where the investigating officer concludes that there is insufficient evidence, no offence is disclosed, the allegations are false, or the dispute is civil in nature, a Final Report, also known as a Closure Report or Cancellation Report, is submitted. A Final Report may broadly be based on: False allegations; Mistake of fact; Mistake of law; Civil nature of the dispute; Insufficient evidence; Untraced accused. Importantly, the Final Report is merely the investigating officer’s opinion. The Magistrate is under no legal obligation to accept it. Is a Protest Petition Recognized under BNSS, 2023? Yes. Although the BNSS does not expressly define a Protest Petition, the legal framework governing police investigations, submission of police reports, cognizance by Magistrates, complaint proceedings, and judicial powers fully supports its maintainability. The law relating to Protest Petitions has primarily evolved through judicial precedents, particularly the decisions of the Supreme Court, which consistently hold that the Magistrate possesses independent authority to examine the police report and determine the appropriate course of action. Consequently, the remedy continues to remain fully available under the BNSS, just as it existed under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. Who Can File a Protest Petition? A Protest Petition may ordinarily be filed by: The complainant or first informant who lodged the FIR. The victim of the offence. Legal representatives of the complainant or victim, where appropriate. Any person authorised under a special statute. The accused generally does not file a Protest Petition because the Final Report itself recommends closure of the criminal proceedings in the accused’s favour. When Should a Protest Petition Be Filed? A Protest Petition should ordinarily be filed after the police submit the Final Report but before the Magistrate formally accepts it. Upon receiving the Final Report, the Magistrate generally provides the complainant with an opportunity to oppose the police report before deciding whether to accept or reject it. Although neither the BNSS nor the earlier CrPC prescribes a specific limitation period for filing a Protest Petition, unnecessary delay should be avoided because acceptance of the Final Report may require the complainant to pursue alternative legal remedies before a superior court. Grounds for Filing a Protest Petition A Protest Petition should be based upon specific legal and factual deficiencies in the police investigation rather than mere dissatisfaction with its outcome. Common grounds include: Failure to examine material witnesses. Ignoring CCTV footage or electronic evidence. Failure to collect documentary evidence. Ignoring medical or forensic reports. Excluding important accused persons. Incorrect appreciation of facts. Treating a criminal offence as a purely civil dispute. Biased, incomplete, or arbitrary investigation. Failure to follow mandatory investigative procedures. Every ground should be supported by relevant facts, documents, and legal principles. How to Draft a Protest Petition A professionally drafted Protest Petition should clearly explain why the Final Report deserves to be rejected. A comprehensive Protest Petition generally includes: Details of the Court and parties. FIR number and police station. Brief facts of the case. Details of the Final Report. Deficiencies in the investigation. Evidence ignored by the police. Relevant statutory provisions. Applicable Supreme Court judgments. Supporting documents. Specific prayer seeking appropriate relief. The petition should avoid emotional allegations and instead rely upon documentary evidence, witness statements, and established legal principles. Documents Required with a Protest Petition Although the documents vary according to the facts of each case, the following documents are commonly annexed: Copy of the FIR. Copy of the Final Report. Medical reports. Certified copies of relevant documents. Photographs and videos. CCTV footage. WhatsApp chats, emails, and other electronic evidence. Expert opinions. Bank records or financial documents, where relevant. Identity documents and authorisations, where necessary. Strong documentary evidence significantly strengthens the credibility of a Protest Petition. Procedure Before the Magistrate The procedure generally follows these stages: The police complete the investigation and submit a Final Report before the Magistrate. The court examines the police papers and ordinarily issues notice to the complainant. The complainant then files a Protest Petition challenging the police report along