Advocate Bhuvnesh Kumar Goyal

Rajasthan High Court Refuses to Confirm Death Penalty in Double Murder Case; Awards Life Imprisonment Till Age of 75 Years

Rajasthan High Court Refuses to Confirm Death Penalty in Double Murder Case; Awards Life Imprisonment Till Age of 75 Years The Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench, has declined to confirm the death penalty awarded to an accused convicted of murdering his wife and six-month-old son, holding that the case did not fall within the category of the “rarest of the rare” cases. While upholding the conviction, the Division Bench modified the death sentence to rigorous imprisonment for life until the convict attains the age of 75 years, without the benefit of statutory remission. The judgment was delivered on 3 October 2026 by a Division Bench comprising Justice Mahendar Kumar Goyal and Justice Praveer Bhatnagar in State of Rajasthan v. Pintu Dagar, D.B. Criminal Death Reference No. 1/2026, connected with D.B. Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 304/2026. The judgment, reported as 2026:RJ-JP:37503-DB, is significant for its detailed examination of the circumstances relevant to the confirmation of a death sentence, particularly the accused’s socio-economic background, possibility of reformation, psychiatric evaluation and conduct during incarceration. Background of the Case The matter arose from an incident dated 1 June 2021 in Kota, Rajasthan. As per the prosecution case, the accused, Pintu Dagar, had assaulted his wife, Seema, with an axe. Their six-month-old son, Avinash @ Rajvir, also sustained injuries during the incident and subsequently died while undergoing treatment. An FIR was registered at Police Station Kotwali, Kota City. During the investigation, the police collected witness statements, medical evidence, forensic material, CCTV-related evidence and other incriminating material. The trial was conducted before the Additional Sessions Judge No. 2, Kota, in Sessions Case No. 387/2021. The prosecution examined 23 witnesses and produced 85 documents during the trial. By judgment dated 22 January 2026, the trial court convicted the accused under Section 302 IPC. By a separate order dated 23 January 2026, the accused was sentenced to death along with a fine of Rs. 50,000. Since the trial court had awarded capital punishment, it forwarded the matter to the Rajasthan High Court under Section 366 CrPC for confirmation of the death sentence. The accused also preferred a criminal appeal challenging his conviction and sentence. Accordingly, the High Court heard the death reference and criminal appeal together and decided both through a common judgment. Arguments Raised Before the Rajasthan High Court The defence challenged the conviction on several grounds, primarily contending that the prosecution case was based on circumstantial evidence and that the chain of circumstances was incomplete. It was argued that nobody had actually witnessed the accused assaulting either his wife or his child. The defence also questioned the prosecution’s reliance on CCTV footage and photographs, the recovery of the alleged weapon of offence, the forensic evidence and the application of Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. It was further argued that the prosecution had failed to establish any motive for the commission of the alleged murders. On the question of sentence, the defence submitted that the case did not satisfy the requirements of the rarest of the rare doctrine. The accused was stated to belong to a socio-economically disadvantaged background, had elderly parents and a surviving minor son, and had demonstrated satisfactory conduct during incarceration. The defence accordingly requested the High Court to reject the death reference and set aside the death sentence. Alternatively, it prayed for commutation of the death sentence to life imprisonment. The State, on the other hand, opposed the appeal and sought confirmation of the death sentence, relying upon the nature of the crime, the vulnerability of the victims and the accused’s criminal antecedents. High Court Upholds Conviction Based on Circumstantial Evidence The Rajasthan High Court first examined the challenge to the conviction. The Bench noted that there was no direct evidence of the accused actually inflicting the injuries upon the deceased persons. Therefore, the prosecution case was required to be examined on the principles governing circumstantial evidence. The Court considered the evidence of witnesses who had seen the accused carrying an axe and dragging his blood-soaked wife by her hair near a shop. It also examined the medical evidence, recovery of the weapon and forensic reports. The Court found that the prosecution had established the following important circumstances: The accused, his wife and their younger son had left the house of Rajesh, the maternal uncle of the deceased, on 1 June 2021. At approximately 7 PM, the accused was seen dragging his blood-soaked wife by her hair near the shop of Vijay Kumar Bhoomliya (PW10), while carrying an axe. The accused had attempted to assault his wife again near the shop but fled after an alarm was raised. The medical evidence established that both Seema and Avinash had died due to injuries sustained by them. Human blood was detected on the articles collected during the investigation. The DNA profile obtained from the clothes of the deceased Seema matched with the DNA profile obtained from the accused’s clothes and the recovered axe. The accused failed to provide a plausible explanation regarding the injuries sustained by his wife and son, which the Court considered relevant under Section 106 of the Evidence Act. The Bench also considered the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116, concerning the appreciation of circumstantial evidence. After examining the evidence, the High Court concluded that the prosecution had successfully established the chain of circumstances beyond reasonable doubt. Important Finding Regarding CCTV Photographs and Section 65B Certificate One particularly important aspect of the judgment concerns the admissibility of electronic evidence. The prosecution had relied upon CCTV footage obtained from a shop and photographs prepared from that footage. The defence questioned the admissibility of the photographs on the ground that they were not supported by the mandatory certificate under Section 65B(4) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The High Court accepted this particular objection. The Bench observed that although the CCTV footage had been copied into a pen drive, the pen drive itself was not played before

Death Penalty in India: Law, Rarest of Rare Doctrine & Procedure

Death Penalty in India: Law, Rarest of Rare Doctrine & Procedure The death penalty, also known as capital punishment, is the most severe form of punishment that can be imposed by a criminal court. It involves the execution of a person who has been convicted of an offence punishable with death, following the completion of the prescribed judicial and constitutional procedures. In India, the death penalty remains a legally recognised punishment, but its imposition is subject to strict constitutional safeguards and judicial restrictions. Indian courts have consistently maintained that capital punishment should not be imposed merely because an offence is serious, shocking or attracts widespread public outrage. Instead, the punishment must satisfy the stringent judicial standard known as the rarest of rare doctrine. The debate surrounding capital punishment involves several important legal and constitutional questions. These include the right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, the possibility of judicial error, the objectives of criminal punishment, the rights of victims, the possibility of reformation of offenders and the role of the State in taking away human life. With the introduction of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), which replaced the Indian Penal Code, 1860, the statutory framework governing offences punishable with death has also undergone changes. This article examines the meaning and legal position of the death penalty in India, its constitutional validity, relevant provisions under the BNS, the rarest of rare doctrine, the procedure for awarding a death sentence, mercy petitions and important judgments of the Supreme Court of India. 1. What Is the Meaning of Death Penalty or Capital Punishment? Death penalty refers to a punishment imposed by a competent court whereby a person convicted of a legally specified offence is sentenced to death. The term capital punishment originates from the Latin word capitalis, referring to something relating to the head. Historically, execution methods varied across jurisdictions. In India, the prescribed method of executing a death sentence is hanging by the neck until death. The death penalty is different from life imprisonment. While life imprisonment involves imprisonment for the remainder of the convict’s natural life, subject to applicable remission and commutation provisions, capital punishment results in the termination of the convict’s life through execution. The principal objectives traditionally associated with capital punishment include: Retribution: Punishing an offender for committing an exceptionally grave crime. Deterrence: Discouraging individuals from committing serious offences. Prevention: Permanently preventing the offender from committing further offences. Justice: Recognising the gravity of certain crimes and their consequences for victims and society. However, the legitimacy and effectiveness of these objectives remain subjects of considerable legal, constitutional and academic debate. 2. Is the Death Penalty Legal in India? Yes. The death penalty is constitutionally valid and legally recognised in India. Indian law does not completely abolish capital punishment. However, the Supreme Court has significantly restricted its application through judicial interpretation of the right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution. The constitutional validity of the death penalty was examined by the Supreme Court in the landmark judgment of Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980). The Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of capital punishment but established that it could be imposed only in the rarest of rare cases. This principle means that the death penalty cannot be imposed as a routine punishment, even where the accused has been convicted of murder or another offence punishable with death. The court must independently examine the circumstances of the offence, the background of the accused, the possibility of rehabilitation and all relevant mitigating circumstances. 3. Constitutional Provisions Governing the Death Penalty in India The Constitution of India does not expressly abolish capital punishment. However, several constitutional provisions regulate the exercise of the State’s power to impose and execute a death sentence. Article 14 – Right to Equality Article 14 guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws. The imposition of capital punishment must comply with the principles of fairness, non-arbitrariness and equality. Courts cannot impose the death penalty arbitrarily or discriminate between similarly situated accused persons without legally sustainable reasons. Article 20 – Protection Against Conviction for Offences Article 20 provides important safeguards to persons accused of criminal offences, including: Protection against retrospective criminal punishment. Protection against being prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once. Protection against being compelled to be a witness against oneself. These protections remain applicable in cases involving capital punishment. Article 21 – Right to Life and Personal Liberty Article 21 provides: “No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.” The right to life is the central constitutional provision in the debate concerning capital punishment. The Supreme Court has interpreted Article 21 to require that any procedure resulting in deprivation of life must be fair, just and reasonable. Consequently, a death sentence can only be imposed after following the procedure established by law and satisfying the constitutional standards developed by judicial precedents. Article 72 – Power of the President to Grant Pardon Article 72 empowers the President of India to grant: Pardon; Reprieve; Respite; Remission; Suspension; or Commutation. The President exercises these powers in cases involving punishment by court martial, offences falling within the executive power of the Union, and all cases where a sentence of death has been imposed. Therefore, even after judicial proceedings conclude, a death-row convict may seek constitutional relief through a mercy petition before the President. Article 161 – Power of the Governor to Grant Pardon Article 161 empowers the Governor of a State to grant pardons, reprieves, respites, remissions, suspensions or commutations of sentences in matters falling within the State’s executive power. However, the Governor’s power under Article 161 does not extend to granting a pardon in a case where a death sentence has been imposed. The constitutional power to pardon a death sentence belongs to the President under Article 72. The Governor may, however, suspend, remit or commute a death sentence under the constitutional framework, subject