Death Penalty in India: Law, Rarest of Rare Doctrine & Procedure
The death penalty, also known as capital punishment, is the most severe form of punishment that can be imposed by a criminal court. It involves the execution of a person who has been convicted of an offence punishable with death, following the completion of the prescribed judicial and constitutional procedures.
In India, the death penalty remains a legally recognised punishment, but its imposition is subject to strict constitutional safeguards and judicial restrictions. Indian courts have consistently maintained that capital punishment should not be imposed merely because an offence is serious, shocking or attracts widespread public outrage. Instead, the punishment must satisfy the stringent judicial standard known as the rarest of rare doctrine.
The debate surrounding capital punishment involves several important legal and constitutional questions. These include the right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, the possibility of judicial error, the objectives of criminal punishment, the rights of victims, the possibility of reformation of offenders and the role of the State in taking away human life.
With the introduction of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), which replaced the Indian Penal Code, 1860, the statutory framework governing offences punishable with death has also undergone changes.
This article examines the meaning and legal position of the death penalty in India, its constitutional validity, relevant provisions under the BNS, the rarest of rare doctrine, the procedure for awarding a death sentence, mercy petitions and important judgments of the Supreme Court of India.
1. What Is the Meaning of Death Penalty or Capital Punishment?
Death penalty refers to a punishment imposed by a competent court whereby a person convicted of a legally specified offence is sentenced to death.
The term capital punishment originates from the Latin word capitalis, referring to something relating to the head. Historically, execution methods varied across jurisdictions. In India, the prescribed method of executing a death sentence is hanging by the neck until death.
The death penalty is different from life imprisonment. While life imprisonment involves imprisonment for the remainder of the convict’s natural life, subject to applicable remission and commutation provisions, capital punishment results in the termination of the convict’s life through execution.
The principal objectives traditionally associated with capital punishment include:
-
Retribution: Punishing an offender for committing an exceptionally grave crime.
-
Deterrence: Discouraging individuals from committing serious offences.
-
Prevention: Permanently preventing the offender from committing further offences.
-
Justice: Recognising the gravity of certain crimes and their consequences for victims and society.
However, the legitimacy and effectiveness of these objectives remain subjects of considerable legal, constitutional and academic debate.
2. Is the Death Penalty Legal in India?
Yes. The death penalty is constitutionally valid and legally recognised in India.
Indian law does not completely abolish capital punishment. However, the Supreme Court has significantly restricted its application through judicial interpretation of the right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution.
The constitutional validity of the death penalty was examined by the Supreme Court in the landmark judgment of Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980).
The Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of capital punishment but established that it could be imposed only in the rarest of rare cases.
This principle means that the death penalty cannot be imposed as a routine punishment, even where the accused has been convicted of murder or another offence punishable with death.
The court must independently examine the circumstances of the offence, the background of the accused, the possibility of rehabilitation and all relevant mitigating circumstances.
3. Constitutional Provisions Governing the Death Penalty in India
The Constitution of India does not expressly abolish capital punishment. However, several constitutional provisions regulate the exercise of the State’s power to impose and execute a death sentence.
Article 14 – Right to Equality
Article 14 guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws.
The imposition of capital punishment must comply with the principles of fairness, non-arbitrariness and equality. Courts cannot impose the death penalty arbitrarily or discriminate between similarly situated accused persons without legally sustainable reasons.
Article 20 – Protection Against Conviction for Offences
Article 20 provides important safeguards to persons accused of criminal offences, including:
-
Protection against retrospective criminal punishment.
-
Protection against being prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once.
-
Protection against being compelled to be a witness against oneself.
These protections remain applicable in cases involving capital punishment.
Article 21 – Right to Life and Personal Liberty
Article 21 provides:
“No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.”
The right to life is the central constitutional provision in the debate concerning capital punishment.
The Supreme Court has interpreted Article 21 to require that any procedure resulting in deprivation of life must be fair, just and reasonable.
Consequently, a death sentence can only be imposed after following the procedure established by law and satisfying the constitutional standards developed by judicial precedents.
Article 72 – Power of the President to Grant Pardon
Article 72 empowers the President of India to grant:
-
Pardon;
-
Reprieve;
-
Respite;
-
Remission;
-
Suspension; or
-
Commutation.
The President exercises these powers in cases involving punishment by court martial, offences falling within the executive power of the Union, and all cases where a sentence of death has been imposed.
Therefore, even after judicial proceedings conclude, a death-row convict may seek constitutional relief through a mercy petition before the President.
Article 161 – Power of the Governor to Grant Pardon
Article 161 empowers the Governor of a State to grant pardons, reprieves, respites, remissions, suspensions or commutations of sentences in matters falling within the State’s executive power.
However, the Governor’s power under Article 161 does not extend to granting a pardon in a case where a death sentence has been imposed. The constitutional power to pardon a death sentence belongs to the President under Article 72.
The Governor may, however, suspend, remit or commute a death sentence under the constitutional framework, subject to applicable legal limitations.
4. Death Penalty Under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS)
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 replaced the Indian Penal Code, 1860, with effect from 1 July 2024.
Section 4 of the BNS expressly recognises death as one of the punishments prescribed under Indian criminal law.
The BNS provides capital punishment for several serious offences. Some of the important provisions include the following:
|
BNS provision |
Offence |
|---|---|
|
Section 66 |
Rape resulting in death or persistent vegetative state of the victim |
|
Section 70(2) |
Gang rape of a woman below 18 years of age |
|
Section 71 |
Repeat offenders committing specified rape offences |
|
Section 103(1) |
Murder |
|
Section 103(2) |
Murder by a group of five or more persons on specified discriminatory grounds |
|
Section 104 |
Murder by a person already sentenced to life imprisonment |
|
Section 107 |
Abetment of suicide of a child or person of unsound mind |
|
Section 109(2) |
Attempt to murder by a person undergoing life imprisonment, where hurt is caused |
|
Section 113(2) |
Terrorist act resulting in death |
|
Section 140(2) |
Kidnapping or abduction for ransom and specified purposes |
|
Section 147 |
Waging or attempting to wage war against the Government of India |
|
Section 160 |
Abetment of mutiny actually committed |
|
Section 230(2) |
Giving or fabricating false evidence resulting in the conviction and execution of an innocent person |
|
Section 310(3) |
Dacoity accompanied by murder |
Important legal clarification: The table identifies important BNS provisions carrying the possibility of capital punishment. The precise statutory ingredients, exceptions and applicable punishment must be examined in each case. Special criminal statutes may also prescribe the death penalty for particular offences.
Section 103(1) is particularly significant because it provides that a person committing murder may be punished with death or imprisonment for life and shall also be liable to fine.
It is important to understand that the mere fact that an offence is punishable with death under the BNS does not mean that the court must impose capital punishment. The constitutional limitations and the rarest of rare doctrine continue to apply.
5. The Rarest of Rare Doctrine: When Can a Court Award the Death Penalty?
The rarest of rare doctrine is the most important judicial principle governing capital punishment in India.
Under this doctrine, the death penalty should be imposed only in exceptional cases where the alternative option of life imprisonment is unquestionably foreclosed.
The doctrine was established by the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 684.
The Supreme Court held that capital punishment should be imposed only in the rarest of rare cases when the alternative option is unquestionably foreclosed.
What Does Rarest of Rare Actually Mean?
The expression does not refer to a fixed numerical category of crimes. It requires a judicial assessment of the facts and circumstances of each individual case.
A crime may be extremely brutal, shocking or socially disturbing. Nevertheless, those factors alone do not automatically justify the imposition of the death penalty.
The court must consider whether the circumstances demonstrate that no alternative punishment is appropriate.
Factors Considered While Imposing the Death Penalty
Courts generally examine two categories of circumstances.
A. Aggravating circumstances
These are factors that may justify a more severe sentence, including:
-
The manner in which the crime was committed.
-
The magnitude and brutality of the offence.
-
The motive behind the commission of the crime.
-
The social position or vulnerability of the victim.
-
The exceptional depravity or premeditated nature of the crime.
-
The criminal history and conduct of the accused, where relevant.
B. Mitigating circumstances
These are factors that may justify a lesser sentence, including:
-
Age of the accused.
-
Possibility of rehabilitation and reformation.
-
Mental and psychological condition.
-
Socio-economic background.
-
Family circumstances and personal history.
-
Absence of previous criminal antecedents.
-
Possibility that the accused may not commit similar offences in the future.
-
Conduct of the accused during incarceration.
The court must give meaningful consideration to mitigating circumstances and cannot mechanically impose capital punishment merely because the crime is particularly heinous.
Life Imprisonment Is the Rule and Death Is the Exception
One of the most significant principles developed by the Supreme Court is that life imprisonment is the normal rule, whereas the death penalty is an exceptional punishment.
Even where an accused is convicted of a particularly serious murder, the court must examine whether life imprisonment would adequately serve the ends of justice.
The death penalty should not be imposed merely to satisfy public sentiment, media pressure or demands for exemplary punishment.
6. Landmark Supreme Court Judgments on Death Penalty in India
The jurisprudence surrounding capital punishment in India has developed through several important decisions of the Supreme Court. These judgments establish the constitutional limitations, sentencing principles and procedural safeguards applicable to death penalty cases.
6.1 Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 684
This is the most significant judgment concerning the constitutional validity of capital punishment in India.
The Supreme Court examined whether the death penalty prescribed under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code violated Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution.
The majority upheld the constitutional validity of capital punishment but restricted its imposition to the rarest of rare cases.
The Court also emphasised that life imprisonment must ordinarily be preferred and that capital punishment should be imposed only where the alternative option is unquestionably foreclosed.
Legal principle established: The death penalty is constitutionally valid, but its imposition must satisfy the rarest of rare doctrine.
6.2 Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab (1983) 3 SCC 470
In this important judgment, the Supreme Court further explained the rarest of rare doctrine laid down in Bachan Singh.
The Court identified certain categories of circumstances that may be relevant while determining whether a murder case falls within the rarest of rare category.
These included:
-
Manner of commission of murder.
-
Motive behind the commission of murder.
-
Magnitude of the crime.
-
Anti-social nature of the crime.
-
Personality and circumstances of the victim.
The Court also recognised the importance of balancing aggravating and mitigating circumstances before imposing capital punishment.
Legal principle established: The gravity and circumstances of the crime must be assessed alongside the circumstances of the accused before deciding whether the death penalty is justified.
6.3 Mithu v. State of Punjab (1983) 2 SCC 277
This judgment is particularly important because it deals with mandatory death sentences.
The Supreme Court struck down Section 303 of the Indian Penal Code, which prescribed mandatory death punishment for a person serving a life sentence who committed murder.
The Court held that mandatory death punishment violated Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution.
The judgment recognised that sentencing must involve judicial consideration of the circumstances of each individual case.
Legal principle established: A mandatory death sentence that removes judicial discretion and ignores individual circumstances is unconstitutional.
This principle is particularly relevant when examining statutory provisions under the new criminal laws.
6.4 Santosh Kumar Satishbhushan Bariyar v. State of Maharashtra (2009) 6 SCC 498
This judgment strengthened the requirement that courts must consider the possibility of rehabilitation before imposing capital punishment.
The Supreme Court emphasised that the death penalty cannot be imposed merely because the crime is exceptionally brutal.
The possibility of reforming the accused must receive serious judicial consideration.
The prosecution must provide material demonstrating why the accused cannot be reformed or rehabilitated before the death penalty can be justified.
Legal principle established: Rehabilitation and reformation are essential considerations in capital sentencing.
6.5 Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India (2014) 3 SCC 1
This judgment deals with the constitutional rights of death-row prisoners, particularly in relation to mercy petitions and delays in execution.
The Supreme Court recognised that unexplained or excessive delay in deciding mercy petitions may constitute a violation of Article 21.
The Court also examined other grounds that may justify commutation of a death sentence, including:
-
Inordinate delay in deciding mercy petitions.
-
Mental illness or insanity.
-
Procedural irregularities.
-
Relevant circumstances concerning the prisoner’s health.
-
Other constitutionally significant circumstances.
Legal principle established: Constitutional safeguards continue to protect a prisoner even after the judicial process has resulted in a final death sentence.
6.6 Manoj v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2022) 2 SCC 353
This judgment is particularly relevant to criminal defence lawyers dealing with death penalty cases.
The Supreme Court emphasised the importance of obtaining relevant information concerning the accused before deciding whether capital punishment should be imposed.
The Court highlighted the need to consider:
-
Socio-economic background.
-
Family circumstances.
-
Mental and psychological health.
-
Educational background.
-
Previous criminal history.
-
Conduct in prison.
-
Possibility of rehabilitation and reformation.
The judgment stressed that a meaningful sentencing hearing is not an empty formality.
The prosecution must place relevant material before the court to establish why the possibility of reformation is unavailable.
Legal principle established: Death penalty sentencing requires a meaningful and individualised assessment of the accused, rather than an exclusive focus on the brutality of the crime.
6.7 Recent Judicial Approach to Capital Punishment
The Supreme Court has continued to emphasise that a finding of guilt for a serious offence and the decision to impose capital punishment are two distinct judicial exercises.
For instance, in its judgment dated 9 November 2023, the Supreme Court reiterated that even a deliberately planned and exceptionally brutal murder does not automatically justify capital punishment if life imprisonment remains an appropriate alternative.
This reinforces the principle that the rarest of rare doctrine requires a separate and careful sentencing assessment.
7. What Is the Legal Procedure for Awarding the Death Penalty in India?
The procedure for imposing and executing capital punishment is governed by the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), the Constitution of India and relevant judicial precedents.
A death sentence passed by a trial court is not automatically executable. It must pass through several judicial and constitutional safeguards.
Step 1: Trial Before the Sessions Court
Most offences punishable with death are triable by the Court of Session.
The prosecution must establish the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt.
The accused is entitled to all protections available under criminal law, including legal representation, the right to challenge prosecution evidence and the right to present a defence.
Step 2: Separate Hearing on the Question of Sentence
After conviction, the court must provide the accused an opportunity to be heard on the question of sentence.
The sentencing hearing is particularly important in capital punishment cases because the court must independently examine whether the case falls within the rarest of rare category.
The accused must be allowed to present mitigating circumstances, including personal history, mental condition, age, family background and prospects of rehabilitation.
Step 3: Recording Special Reasons for Death Sentence
Section 393(3) of the BNSS requires the court to record special reasons when imposing a death sentence.
The court cannot simply state that the crime was brutal or shocking.
It must provide legally sustainable reasons explaining why capital punishment, rather than life imprisonment, is necessary in the particular case.
Section 393(5) further provides that a death sentence shall direct that the person be hanged by the neck until death.
Step 4: Mandatory Confirmation by the High Court
Section 407 of the BNSS provides that whenever a Court of Session passes a sentence of death, the proceedings must be submitted to the High Court for confirmation.
The death sentence cannot be executed unless it is confirmed by the High Court.
This is an extremely important safeguard because the High Court independently examines the correctness of the conviction and the legality and appropriateness of the sentence.
Under Section 409 of the BNSS, the High Court may:
-
Confirm the death sentence.
-
Pass any other sentence authorised by law.
-
Annul the conviction.
-
Order a retrial.
-
Acquit the accused.
Therefore, the High Court is not merely required to approve the decision of the Sessions Court. It has the authority to independently examine the entire matter.
Step 5: Appeal Before the Supreme Court
If the High Court confirms the death sentence, the convicted person may pursue the remedies available before the Supreme Court.
Article 134 of the Constitution provides for criminal appeals to the Supreme Court in specified circumstances.
Article 136 also empowers the Supreme Court to grant special leave to appeal.
The Supreme Court may examine the conviction, the appreciation of evidence, the legality of the sentence and the application of the rarest of rare doctrine.
Step 6: Review Petition and Curative Petition
After the Supreme Court decides the appeal, the convicted person may seek review of the judgment in accordance with Article 137 of the Constitution and the applicable procedural rules.
A curative petition may also be filed in exceptional circumstances, subject to the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra (2002) 4 SCC 388.
These remedies are important safeguards against miscarriage of justice.
Step 7: Mercy Petition Before the Governor and President
Even after the judicial remedies are exhausted, the convict may seek constitutional relief by filing a mercy petition.
The relevant constitutional provisions are Article 161 and Article 72.
The President and Governor exercise their respective constitutional powers in accordance with the constitutional scheme and applicable legal principles.
Step 8: Execution of Death Sentence
A death sentence can be executed only after the mandatory judicial confirmation and applicable appellate and constitutional procedures have been completed.
The BNSS prescribes the method of execution as hanging by the neck until death.
The execution process is also subject to the applicable prison rules and safeguards.
8. What Is a Mercy Petition in a Death Penalty Case?
A mercy petition is a constitutional representation seeking relief from a sentence imposed by a court.
It is an important safeguard available to a person sentenced to death.
A mercy petition does not function as another criminal appeal. Instead, it invokes the constitutional powers of the executive to reconsider the punishment in light of relevant circumstances.
Who Can Grant Mercy in a Death Penalty Case?
The President of India – Article 72
The President has constitutional power to grant pardon, reprieve, respite, remission, suspension or commutation in cases involving a death sentence.
The Governor – Article 161
The Governor may exercise the powers of suspension, remission or commutation in accordance with Article 161, but cannot grant a pardon in a death sentence case.
Grounds for Filing a Mercy Petition
A mercy petition may raise several grounds, including:
-
Excessive delay in deciding the mercy petition.
-
Deterioration of mental or physical health.
-
Mental illness or psychological disability.
-
Relevant circumstances concerning the convict’s family.
-
Disproportionate punishment.
-
Procedural irregularities.
-
Other humanitarian and constitutional considerations.
The Supreme Court has recognised that the executive’s power of clemency is not beyond judicial review. Its exercise must conform to constitutional principles.
9. Can a Death Sentence Be Commuted to Life Imprisonment?
Yes. A death sentence can be commuted to life imprisonment.
Commutation means substituting one form of punishment with a lesser punishment.
The power to commute a death sentence may arise under constitutional provisions and applicable statutory provisions.
A death sentence may be commuted in circumstances such as:
-
Failure to satisfy the rarest of rare doctrine.
-
Failure to properly consider mitigating circumstances.
-
Non-compliance with mandatory sentencing safeguards.
-
Excessive and unexplained delay in deciding a mercy petition.
-
Relevant mental or physical health conditions.
-
Other circumstances recognised by constitutional and criminal law.
It is important to distinguish between ordinary life imprisonment and life imprisonment for the remainder of the convict’s natural life.
The Supreme Court has recognised the possibility of imposing special-category life sentences, including imprisonment for the remainder of natural life, in appropriate cases.
Therefore, the choice before a court is not necessarily limited to ordinary life imprisonment or death.
As per the Top Criminal Lawyers in Jaipur, recently Rajasthan High Court Jaipur Bench in a double murder case refused to confirm the death penalty and instead converted it into life imprisonment upto 75 years of age in case of double murder case by Pintu Dagar
10. Death Penalty and the Right to Rehabilitation
One of the most important developments in Indian capital punishment jurisprudence is the recognition that the possibility of rehabilitation must be considered before imposing the death penalty.
The criminal justice system is not concerned only with punishment. It also recognises the objectives of reforming offenders and facilitating their reintegration into society.
The possibility of rehabilitation becomes particularly significant in capital punishment cases because execution is irreversible.
The Supreme Court’s decision in Manoj v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2022) reinforces the importance of obtaining relevant information about the accused before making a final sentencing decision.
Courts should not assume that an accused person is incapable of reform merely because the offence is particularly grave.
The prosecution and defence must be given an appropriate opportunity to present relevant sentencing material.
11. Arguments in Favour of and Against Capital Punishment
Capital punishment remains one of the most debated subjects in criminal jurisprudence.
There are arguments supporting its retention as well as arguments advocating its abolition.
Arguments in Favour of Death Penalty
1. Deterrence against serious crimes
Supporters argue that the possibility of capital punishment may discourage individuals from committing exceptionally serious offences.
2. Proportionality of punishment
Some believe that certain exceptionally grave offences deserve the highest possible punishment.
3. Protection of society
Capital punishment permanently prevents the offender from committing further crimes after execution.
4. Justice for victims
Supporters argue that the punishment recognises the seriousness of the harm suffered by victims and their families.
Arguments Against Death Penalty
1. Possibility of wrongful conviction
No criminal justice system is entirely free from error. If an innocent person is executed, the mistake cannot be corrected.
2. Irreversibility
Unlike imprisonment, capital punishment cannot be reversed after execution.
3. Questionable deterrent effect
There is continuing debate about whether capital punishment is demonstrably more effective than life imprisonment in preventing serious crimes.
4. Possibility of rehabilitation
Even individuals convicted of extremely serious offences may undergo significant personal transformation.
5. Human rights concerns
Abolitionists argue that the State should not have the power to take the life of an individual as punishment.
Top High Court Lawyers in Jaipur suggests that The debate ultimately involves balancing the interests of society, victims, constitutional rights and the objectives of criminal justice. Moreover, as the nation saw the case of Nirbhaya, in such matters it becomes more and more compelling to keep the laws of death penalty as in the end it is the legislature who enact laws and when the public and citizens who elects the members of the legislatures demands death penalty then the legislature sometimes are also left with no choice but to enact such laws as being demanded for the satisfaction of the citizens at large.
12. Death Penalty in India: International Human Rights Perspective
The death penalty is also an important subject of international human rights law.
Article 3 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights recognises the right to life, liberty and security of person.
Article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) recognises the inherent right to life and places restrictions on the use of capital punishment in countries that have not abolished it.
The Second Optional Protocol to the ICCPR aims at the abolition of the death penalty.
India is a party to the ICCPR but has not ratified the Second Optional Protocol.
Consequently, India continues to retain capital punishment within its domestic legal framework, subject to constitutional and judicial safeguards.
13. Death Penalty in India: Latest Position and Developments
The administration of capital punishment in India continues to receive significant attention from courts, legal researchers and human rights organisations.
The Death Penalty in India: Annual Statistics Report 2025, published by The Square Circle Clinic (formerly Project 39A) on 4 February 2026, marks ten years of systematic documentation of death penalty cases in India.
The report examines developments in capital sentencing, judicial decisions and the implementation of Supreme Court directions concerning sentencing materials, including the mental health, personal circumstances and rehabilitation prospects of accused persons.
It is particularly relevant for understanding how capital punishment is administered in practice, beyond the statutory provisions.
The continuing judicial emphasis on sentencing safeguards demonstrates that capital punishment is not simply a question of the seriousness of the offence. It also requires an individualised assessment of the accused and the constitutional limitations on the power of the State.
14. Conclusion: Is Capital Punishment Justified Under Indian Law?
The death penalty occupies a unique position in the Indian criminal justice system. Although it remains constitutionally valid, its application is subject to strict judicial and constitutional limitations.
The Supreme Court, through landmark judgments such as Bachan Singh, Machhi Singh, Mithu, Shatrughan Chauhan and Manoj, has developed a framework intended to prevent arbitrary or excessive use of capital punishment.
The rarest of rare doctrine ensures that the death penalty is not imposed merely because a crime is brutal, shocking or socially unacceptable. Courts must consider aggravating and mitigating circumstances, the possibility of rehabilitation and whether any alternative punishment would adequately serve the ends of justice.
The introduction of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, has retained capital punishment for several serious offences. However, the constitutional safeguards developed under the earlier criminal law framework continue to govern the imposition of death sentences.
Ultimately, the most important principle of Indian capital punishment jurisprudence remains that the power of the State to take away human life must be exercised only in exceptional circumstances and in strict compliance with constitutional requirements.
15. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Death Penalty in India
Q1. Is the death penalty constitutional in India?
Yes. The Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of capital punishment in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 684. However, it restricted its imposition to the rarest of rare cases.
Q2. What is the rarest of rare doctrine?
The rarest of rare doctrine is a judicial principle under which capital punishment may be imposed only in exceptional cases where the alternative option of life imprisonment is unquestionably foreclosed.
Q3. Which section of BNS provides for the death penalty for murder?
Section 103(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, provides for death or imprisonment for life, along with fine, as punishment for murder.
Q4. Can a Sessions Court directly execute a death sentence?
No. Under Section 407 of the BNSS, a death sentence passed by the Sessions Court must be submitted to the High Court for confirmation. It cannot be executed without such confirmation.
Q5. Can the High Court cancel a death sentence?
Yes. Under Section 409 of the BNSS, the High Court may confirm the death sentence, impose another legally permissible sentence, annul the conviction, order a retrial or acquit the accused.
Q6. Can the President of India cancel or reduce a death sentence?
Yes. Under Article 72 of the Constitution, the President can grant pardon, reprieve, respite, remission, suspension or commutation in cases involving a death sentence.
Q7. Can the Governor commute a death sentence?
Yes. The Governor may exercise the constitutional powers of suspension, remission or commutation under Article 161, subject to applicable constitutional limitations. However, the Governor cannot grant a pardon in a death sentence case.
Q8. Can a death sentence be reduced because of delay in execution?
Yes. Unexplained and excessive delay in deciding a mercy petition may constitute a ground for commutation of a death sentence, as recognised in Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India (2014) 3 SCC 1.
Q9. Is death penalty mandatory for murder in India?
No. Section 103 of the BNS provides death or life imprisonment as alternative punishments. The court must exercise judicial discretion and apply the rarest of rare doctrine.
Q10. What is the difference between life imprisonment and the death penalty?
Life imprisonment involves incarceration for the convict’s natural life, subject to applicable remission and commutation provisions. The death penalty involves execution following completion of the prescribed legal procedures.
Q11. Can a person sentenced to death file an appeal?
Yes. The accused can pursue the applicable appellate remedies before the High Court and Supreme Court, followed by review and, in exceptional circumstances, curative proceedings.
Q12. What is the last stage before execution of a death sentence?
After the judicial remedies and applicable constitutional processes have been exhausted, the execution process may proceed in accordance with the BNSS and applicable prison rules, provided no subsisting order prevents execution.
16. Important Legal Provisions and Judgments at a Glance
|
Subject |
Relevant provision / judgment |
|---|---|
|
Death as a punishment |
Section 4, BNS |
|
Murder |
Section 103, BNS |
|
Murder by life convict |
Section 104, BNS |
|
Special reasons for death sentence |
Section 393(3), BNSS |
|
Execution by hanging |
Section 393(5), BNSS |
|
Confirmation by High Court |
Section 407, BNSS |
|
High Court’s powers |
Section 409, BNSS |
|
President’s mercy powers |
Article 72, Constitution |
|
Governor’s mercy powers |
Article 161, Constitution |
|
Constitutional validity |
Bachan Singh (1980) |
|
Rarest of rare doctrine |
Bachan Singh (1980) |
|
Aggravating and mitigating circumstances |
Machhi Singh (1983) |
|
Mandatory death penalty |
Mithu (1983) |
|
Delay in mercy petitions |
Shatrughan Chauhan (2014) |
|
Rehabilitation and sentencing |
Manoj (2022) |