Advocate Bhuvnesh Kumar Goyal

Rajasthan High Court on Judicial Interference in Panchayat Elections: Article 243-O Bars Reopening of Reservation Exercise After Publication of Election Programme

In an important judgment concerning Panchayati Raj elections in Rajasthan, the Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench, has examined the constitutional limitations on judicial interference in the electoral process, particularly in matters relating to reservation of seats for Gram Panchayats.

In State of Rajasthan & Ors. v. Mahendra Singh & Ors., D.B. Special Appeal Writ Nos. 1227/2026, 1228/2026 and 1230/2026, decided on 2 November 2026, the Division Bench comprising Hon’ble Chief Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sameer Jain held that once the State Election Commission has published the election programme, a direction for conducting a fresh reservation exercise cannot ordinarily be permitted if it has the effect of reopening or altering the notified electoral arrangements.

The judgment reiterates the constitutional significance of Article 243-O of the Constitution of India and emphasises that election-related disputes must be addressed through the remedies prescribed under the applicable election laws.

Importantly, the High Court clarified that it was not deciding the substantive correctness of the reservation allocation. Its decision was confined to the question of whether judicial directions could reopen the reservation exercise during the subsistence of an already notified election programme.

Background of the Case

The dispute arose out of the reservation exercise undertaken by the State authorities for the 2026 Panchayati Raj elections in Rajasthan.

The respondents had challenged the reservation lottery conducted on 24 September 2026 concerning the relevant Gram Panchayats. Their grievance was that the reservation exercise had not been undertaken in accordance with Rule 7 of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj (Election) Rules, 1994, and the applicable administrative circulars.

The principal controversy concerned the implementation of the reservation roster and the constitutional principle of rotation of reserved seats.

The respondents contended that certain Gram Panchayats had already been reserved for particular categories in previous elections and, therefore, could not again be reserved without first demonstrating that the existing reservation roster had been exhausted.

They also questioned the methodology adopted by the authorities while determining reservations for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.

The learned Single Judge, by an order dated 1 October 2026, allowed the writ petition and quashed the reservation lottery dated 24 September 2026 to the extent challenged. The authorities were directed to undertake a fresh reservation exercise in accordance with Rule 7 of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj (Election) Rules, 1994, and the applicable administrative circulars.

Aggrieved by the decision, the State authorities preferred special appeals before the Division Bench.

A significant subsequent development was that the State Election Commission published the Panchayati Raj election programme on 3 October 2026, after the Single Judge had passed the order.

This subsequent development became central to the adjudication of the special appeals.

Contentions Raised by the State Authorities

The State authorities challenged the Single Judge’s decision primarily on the ground that the reservation exercise had been conducted in accordance with Rule 7 of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj (Election) Rules, 1994, and the administrative circulars dated 10 August 2026, 16 August 2026 and 19 September 2026.

It was argued that the administrative circulars had been issued to address procedural difficulties arising out of the reconstitution and delimitation of Panchayat circles.

The State further submitted that the principle of rotation had been duly followed and that the category reserved in the preceding election had not been reserved again in the concerned Gram Panchayat.

Another important submission was that there is no fundamental right to contest an election from a particular constituency or against a particular reservation category.

The State also contended that the reservation methodology for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes was based on their overall population within the respective Panchayat Samiti and not merely on their population in an individual Gram Panchayat.

With respect to the constitutional bar under Article 243-O, the State argued that once the election programme had been notified on 3 October 2026, the High Court ought not to have issued directions that could interrupt or alter the ongoing election process.

The State relied upon the constitutional scheme governing Panchayat elections and the principle that election disputes should ordinarily be raised through election petitions.

Submissions on Behalf of the Respondents

On the other hand, the respondents defended the order passed by the learned Single Judge.

Their principal argument was that the reservation exercise was contrary to Article 243-D of the Constitution, Section 16 of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj Act, 1994, Rule 7 of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj (Election) Rules, 1994, and the relevant administrative circulars.

It was submitted that reservation by rotation is a mandatory constitutional requirement and that the authorities could not arbitrarily restart the reservation cycle without establishing that the existing roster had been exhausted.

The respondents further contended that the circular dated 10 August 2026 required continuation of the existing reservation cycle in Panchayat Samitis that had been reorganised or remained unchanged.

They also relied upon the subsequent clarification dated 19 September 2026, which, according to their submissions, required the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe reservation roster to be reckoned from 1994.

Another significant argument was that the election notification for the concerned Gram Panchayat had not yet been issued and that polling was scheduled for a later phase.

Therefore, according to the respondents, implementation of the Single Judge’s directions would not delay or obstruct the election process.

They also relied upon the Supreme Court’s judgment in Election Commission of India v. Ashok Kumar, (2000) 8 SCC 216, to contend that judicial intervention which facilitates and furthers the election process without interrupting or delaying it is permissible.

Article 243-O of the Constitution of India: Constitutional Bar on Interference in Panchayat Elections

The central legal issue before the Division Bench concerned the interpretation and application of Article 243-O of the Constitution of India.

Article 243-O provides a constitutional safeguard against judicial interference in electoral matters concerning Panchayats.

It reads as follows:

Article 243-O: Bar to interference by courts in electoral matters

Notwithstanding anything in the Constitution:

(a) The validity of any law relating to the delimitation of constituencies or the allotment of seats to such constituencies made or purporting to be made under Article 243K shall not be called in question in any court.

(b) No election to any Panchayat shall be called in question except by an election petition presented to such authority and in such manner as is provided for by or under any law made by the Legislature of a State.

The constitutional provision essentially seeks to ensure that the election process is completed without being interrupted by repeated judicial proceedings at different stages.

The mechanism of election petitions is intended to provide an appropriate forum for adjudicating election-related disputes in accordance with the applicable statutory framework.

The High Court observed that the constitutional scheme envisages adjudication of electoral disputes through the prescribed statutory mechanism, thereby ensuring timely completion of elections and constitution of duly elected local self-government institutions.

Whether the High Court Can Interfere Under Article 226 During Panchayat Elections?

One of the most important aspects of the judgment is the Court’s discussion concerning the scope of judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution.

The Division Bench clarified that Article 243-O does not completely eliminate the constitutional power of judicial review under Article 226 in every circumstance connected with elections.

However, the exercise of such jurisdiction is subject to the constitutional restrictions governing electoral disputes and, importantly, the nature and effect of the relief sought.

The Court observed that merely alleging that an administrative action is contrary to statutory rules or executive instructions cannot, by itself, justify an order that has the effect of reopening or altering electoral arrangements after publication of the election programme.

Therefore, the Court emphasised that the nature of the relief sought is an important consideration while examining whether judicial interference is permissible.

Even where a litigant raises a substantial grievance concerning an allegedly illegal administrative decision, the remedy must be pursued consistently with the constitutional and statutory framework governing elections.

This principle assumes particular importance in disputes concerning reservation of seats, delimitation, electoral constituencies and other administrative arrangements connected with Panchayat elections.

Publication of Election Programme: A Material Stage in the Electoral Process

The most significant aspect of the judgment concerns the legal consequences of publication of the election programme by the State Election Commission.

The learned Single Judge had passed the order on 1 October 2026, whereas the State Election Commission published the election programme on 3 October 2026.

The Division Bench treated the publication of the election programme as a material stage in the electoral process.

The Court observed that once the election programme has been published and remains operative, the authorities entrusted with conducting elections are required to proceed in accordance with the notified schedule.

In the present case, the State Election Commission had declared elections for:

  • 41 Zila Parishads comprising 1,403 wards.

  • 457 Panchayat Samitis comprising 8,245 wards.

  • 14,403 Village Panchayats comprising 1,30,589 wards.

  • More than four crore voters.

The election programme contemplated elections in four phases, with the fourth phase scheduled to conclude on 17 November 2026.

Considering the extensive nature of the electoral exercise, the Court held that reopening reservation arrangements during the subsistence of the notified election programme could affect the continuity and orderly completion of the elections.

The Court further held that the electoral process must be considered as an integrated exercise comprising successive stages.

Consequently, the fact that the individual election notification for a particular Gram Panchayat had not yet been issued would not, by itself, permit reopening of the reservation exercise through judicial directions that could affect the notified electoral arrangements.

This observation is particularly significant because the respondents had argued that polling in the concerned Gram Panchayat was scheduled for a subsequent phase and, therefore, there was sufficient time to undertake a fresh reservation exercise.

The Division Bench did not accept this argument.

Can an Illegal Reservation Lottery Be Challenged After Publication of the Election Programme?

The judgment addresses an important practical question concerning challenges to reservation lotteries.

The respondents had argued that the reservation lottery was contrary to Rule 7 of the Rajasthan Panchayati Raj (Election) Rules, 1994, and the applicable circulars.

However, the Division Bench distinguished between the existence of an arguable grievance on the merits and the permissibility of granting a particular relief during an ongoing election process.

The Court observed that the importance of reservation by rotation under Article 243-D of the Constitution and the applicable statutory rules cannot be understated.

Nevertheless, even where a grievance concerning reservation is substantial, the remedy must be pursued in accordance with the applicable constitutional and statutory framework.

The Court held that the constitutional bar cannot be circumvented merely by describing the challenge as one concerning an administrative lottery when, in substance, the relief sought would alter the reservation arrangement governing the ensuing election.

Thus, the judgment emphasises that the nature and practical consequences of the relief sought are crucial considerations in deciding whether judicial intervention is permissible.

Supreme Court Judgments Considered by the Rajasthan High Court

The Division Bench considered several important Supreme Court decisions while examining the limits of judicial interference in election matters.

1. Election Commission of India v. Ashok Kumar, (2000) 8 SCC 216

The Supreme Court explained the distinction between permissible judicial intervention and interference that obstructs or delays an election.

Judicial intervention may be permissible where it facilitates and furthers the election process without interrupting, obstructing or delaying the proceedings.

Conversely, judicial intervention that impedes the electoral process or results in its postponement cannot ordinarily be justified merely because a party seeks correction of an alleged illegality.

The Rajasthan High Court applied this principle while examining the consequences of directing a fresh reservation lottery after publication of the election programme.

2. Lakshmi Charan Sen v. A.K.M. Hassan Uzzaman, (1985) 4 SCC 689

The judgment was considered in the context of the constitutional requirement that electoral processes should not be unnecessarily interrupted through judicial proceedings.

3. N.P. Ponnuswami v. Returning Officer, Namakkal Constituency, (1952) 1 SCC 94

The Supreme Court’s decision forms part of the established jurisprudence concerning judicial interference in election matters and the principle that election-related grievances should ordinarily be addressed through the prescribed election remedy.

4. Anuragh Narain Singh v. State of U.P., (1996) 6 SCC 303

This decision was also considered while examining the limits of judicial intervention during an ongoing electoral process.

5. Sandeep Singh Bora v. Narendra Singh Deopa, 2026 INSC 105

The Rajasthan High Court also referred to the Supreme Court’s decision dated 2 February 2026.

The Supreme Court emphasised the constitutional embargo under Article 243-O and the requirement that Panchayat election disputes be pursued through the statutory election petition mechanism where such a remedy is available.

The Court observed that individual grievances cannot be permitted to derail or obstruct the electoral process when the governing State law provides an efficacious remedy by way of an election petition.

Final Decision of the Division Bench

After examining the rival submissions, constitutional provisions and relevant judicial precedents, the Division Bench allowed the special appeals preferred by the State authorities.

The Court held that the Single Judge’s direction requiring a fresh reservation exercise could not be sustained during the subsistence of the notified election programme dated 3 October 2026.

Accordingly, the Court directed that the reservation lottery shall not be reopened pursuant to the directions contained in the impugned judgment during the subsistence of the election programme.

However, the Court made an important clarification in paragraph 26 of its judgment.

Top Advocate in Jaipur informed that the order expressly stated that it had not adjudicated upon the correctness of the reservation allocation on its substantive merits.

The observations made by the Court were confined to the question of judicial interference in view of the notified election programme.

No opinion was expressed on any issue that may arise for consideration before the competent forum in proceedings maintainable under the applicable law.

Thus, the decision was based on the constitutional limitations governing interference with an ongoing election process and not on a final determination that the reservation lottery itself was legally correct.

Legal Significance and Implications of the Judgment

The judgment carries considerable significance for Panchayati Raj elections and election-related litigation in Rajasthan.

1. Election disputes must follow the prescribed statutory remedy

The judgment reiterates that election-related grievances must ordinarily be raised through the election petition mechanism prescribed under the applicable law.

2. Publication of the election programme is a material stage

Once the State Election Commission publishes the election programme, the electoral process assumes an integrated character. Judicial directions affecting the notified arrangements must be examined with particular caution.

3. Article 243-O does not completely eliminate judicial review

The Court clarified that Article 243-O does not extinguish the power of judicial review under Article 226 in every election-related circumstance. However, such jurisdiction remains subject to constitutional limitations and the effect of the relief sought.

4. Alleged illegality in reservation does not automatically justify reopening the election arrangements

Even where a party raises a substantial grievance concerning violation of reservation rules or rotation principles, the remedy must conform to the applicable electoral framework.

5. Individual election notifications are not the sole determining factor

The absence of an individual election notification for a particular Gram Panchayat does not automatically permit the reservation process to be reopened once the general election programme has been published and remains operative.

6. Reservation rotation remains an important constitutional requirement

The judgment does not dilute the importance of Article 243-D or the principle of rotation. Rather, it distinguishes the substantive legality of reservation from the procedural and constitutional limitations on the timing and manner of judicial intervention.

Conclusion

The judgment of the Rajasthan High Court in State of Rajasthan & Ors. v. Mahendra Singh & Ors., decided on 2 November 2026, reinforces the constitutional principle that elections to Panchayati Raj Institutions must be conducted in a timely, orderly and uninterrupted manner.

The Division Bench has clarified that publication of the election programme is a material stage in the electoral process and that judicial directions which reopen reservation arrangements during the subsistence of such a programme may be inconsistent with Article 243-O of the Constitution.

At the same time, the Court has preserved the distinction between the substantive legality of a reservation exercise and the permissible scope of judicial intervention during an ongoing election.

The central takeaway from this judgment is that an allegation of illegality in a Panchayat reservation exercise does not, by itself, entitle a litigant to obtain a direction for fresh reservation once the election programme has been notified, particularly where such a direction may affect the continuity of the electoral process.

The judgment therefore provides important guidance for future litigation concerning reservation of Gram Panchayats, rotation of reserved seats and judicial review of administrative decisions connected with local-body elections in Rajasthan.

Order